Source: https://guthlabs.ai/docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/field-guides/

job / candidate

# Evidence reconciliation — field guides

The distinct field guides record for Evidence reconciliation. This page is proposal-only.

Status: **proposed**Lifecycle: **candidate**

## Record status

**Record ID**: job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation

**Parent lifecycle**: candidate

**Page lane**: docs_urls

**Lane lifecycle**: proposed

**Owner**: Tilly

**Owner role**: Pointguard and independent reviewer

**Owner status**: WORKING

**Qualification result**: NOT RUN · held for evidence and human review

**Working browser surface:** [Agent jobs — builder overview](<https://guthlabs.ai/guth.html#builder>) — Inspect the package and stage a local project. This route is local-only; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, deployment, and production effects remain held.

## Related field-guide records

- /app/notebook/field-guides/

Source-proposed guide paths are references, not proof that those paths resolve.

## Operating sequence

- Create a local review record linked to the requesting agent, claim, and source records.

- Capture the exact claim wording and its intended audience, scope, and deadline.

- Collect source locators, provenance, revisions, and hashes without altering another agent's source.

- Run citation checks and compare every material assertion with its cited receipt.

- Record instrument work and qualification evidence separately from narrative conclusions.

- Identify contradictions, missing receipts, stale revisions, and claims that exceed the evidence.

- Check principal gates for publication, funding, credential access, and source changes.

- Mark the outcome Needs review, Approved, or Held; Tilly must not approve her own evidence.

- Create bounded correction tasks with owners and due dates using Notebook to-dos.

- Preserve the review receipt in Agent Logs and link the outcome to the relevant PointGuard room.

- Keep any public-claim route, final publication, external send, provider effect, and production effect held for authorized human review.

## Handoff boundary

- A citation or checksum may verify identity or presence without proving the claim is true.

- A draft, local approval, or indexed route may be mistaken for publication or production authority.

- Tilly may be pressured to approve her own instrument work or evidence.

- Contradictions may be hidden by summarization, revision loss, or selective source linking.

- A stale source revision may be treated as current without recording provenance and hash state.

- Qualification, grant, credential, or funding language may imply authorization not present in the records.

- Instrument outputs may be overinterpreted beyond their stated educational or estimator limitations.

- Private evidence may leak into public-claim preparation or customer-facing surfaces.

- Missing deadlines may cause silent drift or unreviewed publication pressure.

- Provider, database, credential, customer, upload, send, and production effects are not established by the available routes.

## Sources and evidence

These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.

- `agents/index.html#tilly`

- `source_record:job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation`

- `job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation`

- `Observed native contract: Notebook records, deadlines, PointGuard, lifecycle, provenance, and held web boundary`

- `App routes: /app/pointguard/, /app/notebook/agent-logs/, /app/notebook/approvals/, /app/notebook/field-guides/, /app/notebook/search/`

- `Allowed instruments: checksum-verifier`

- `Allowed instruments: binary-text-diff-similarity-ratio`

- `source record job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation`

- `Observed native contract: PointGuard`

- `Observed native contract: records`

- `Observed native contract: deadlines`

- `Observed native contract: web boundary`

- `App route /app/pointguard/`

- `App route /app/notebook/field-guides/`

- `App route /app/notebook/agent-logs/`

- `App route /app/notebook/approvals/`

- `App route /app/notebook/search/`

- `Allowed instrument checksum-verifier`