Source: https://guthlabs.ai/docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/forms/ job / candidate # Evidence reconciliation โ€” forms The distinct forms record for Evidence reconciliation. This page is proposal-only. Status: **proposed**Lifecycle: **candidate** ## Record status **Record ID**: job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation **Parent lifecycle**: candidate **Page lane**: package **Lane lifecycle**: proposed **Owner**: Tilly **Owner role**: Pointguard and independent reviewer **Owner status**: WORKING **Qualification result**: NOT RUN ยท held for evidence and human review **Working browser surface:** [Agent jobs โ€” builder overview]() โ€” Inspect the package and stage a local project. This route is local-only; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, deployment, and production effects remain held. ## Proposed form sections Each section is a candidate schema for inspectable records. Required-field presence does not establish factual truth. ### Review intake Define the review target and prevent scope drift. - review title - requesting agent or owner - claim or decision under review - review scope - source record IDs - requested completion date - priority - conflicts disclosed - independent reviewer assigned ### Evidence ledger Map each claim to inspectable receipts. - claim text - claim type - source locator - source SHA-256 - source revision - citation status - instrument output link - qualification status - contradiction status - missing evidence - review notes ### Authority and gate check Record boundaries for actions Tilly may not approve or execute. - final publication affected - funding commitment affected - credential access affected - another agent source change requested - self-approval detected - external provider or database effect - decision state: needs review, approved, held - authorizing reviewer - decision receipt ### Reconciliation outcome Produce a bounded review result and explicit next actions. - finding summary - supported claims - unsupported claims - contradictions - held claims - required corrections - owner for each correction - deadline - workback tasks - final disposition - reviewer signature or receipt ### Accessible state contract - Every field requires a visible and programmatic label. - Required and optional fields must be stated in text. - Invalid entries require an actionable message linked to the field. - Blocked and Held states remain visible without relying on color alone. ## Supporting documentation fields These fields come from the docs_urls lane and remain separate from the primary operating form. ### Job context Identify the review request and preserve ownership boundaries. - request title - requesting agent or person - request date - Tilly review status - scope of review - owner_agent - owner_role - linked job ID ### Claims under review Separate individual claims so each can be traced to evidence without combining unsupported conclusions. - claim text - claim type - claimant - intended audience - claim scope - claim status: draft, supported, contradicted, unresolved, held - public-claim candidate: yes/no - linked claim IDs ### Evidence and citations Capture source-backed receipts and make their provenance inspectable. - source title - source locator - source SHA-256 - source origin - source date or revision - evidence excerpt or observation - receipt owner - linked claim IDs - citation check result - missing-evidence note ### Reconciliation findings Record agreement, contradiction, qualification, and the reason a claim may not proceed. - finding type - supporting evidence IDs - contradicting evidence IDs - qualification required - uncertainty or limitation - reviewer note - resolution status - escalation target ### Gates and disposition Prevent evidence review from becoming unauthorized approval or publication. - gate type - proposed action - decision: approved locally, needs review, held - decision authority - decision receipt - final publication held: yes/no - funding commitment held: yes/no - credential access held: yes/no - cross-agent source change held: yes/no ## Required or proposed record references No record existence is asserted by this documentation page. - source record with canonical ID, origin, locator, SHA-256, provenance, revision, lifecycle, and links - claim record with exact wording, owner, scope, status, and supporting evidence links - citation-check record - instrument-work record - qualification record - grant dossier - public-claim review record - contradiction or unresolved-question record - approval or held-decision record - agent-log receipt - canonical job record with owner_agent Tilly and owner_role Pointguard and independent reviewer - claim record containing claim text, status, claimant, scope, and linked source receipts - citation-check record containing source locator, source SHA-256 when available, provenance, revision, and check result - qualification record for instrument or evidence checks - contradiction record with competing claims, evidence links, reviewer note, and unresolved state - approval record for proposed publication, funding commitment, credential access, or cross-agent source change - agent log receipt recording actions, authority boundaries, and held outcomes ## Sources and evidence These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment. - `agents/index.html#tilly` - `source_record:job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation` - `job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation` - `Observed native contract: Notebook records, deadlines, PointGuard, lifecycle, provenance, and held web boundary` - `App routes: /app/pointguard/, /app/notebook/agent-logs/, /app/notebook/approvals/, /app/notebook/field-guides/, /app/notebook/search/` - `Allowed instruments: checksum-verifier` - `Allowed instruments: binary-text-diff-similarity-ratio` - `source record job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation` - `Observed native contract: PointGuard` - `Observed native contract: records` - `Observed native contract: deadlines` - `Observed native contract: web boundary` - `App route /app/pointguard/` - `App route /app/notebook/field-guides/` - `App route /app/notebook/agent-logs/` - `App route /app/notebook/approvals/` - `App route /app/notebook/search/` - `Allowed instrument checksum-verifier`