Source: https://guthlabs.ai/docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/ job / candidate # Evidence reconciliation A proposal-only review job for Tilly to reconcile claims with source records, citations, instrument outputs, qualification checks, grants, and publication boundaries without approving her own evidence or changing another agent's source. Status: **candidate**Lifecycle: **candidate** ## Record status **Record ID**: job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation **Parent lifecycle**: candidate **Page lane**: catalog overview **Lane lifecycle**: candidate **Owner**: Tilly **Owner role**: Pointguard and independent reviewer **Owner status**: WORKING **Qualification result**: NOT RUN · held for evidence and human review **Working browser surface:** [Agent jobs — builder overview]() — Inspect the package and stage a local project. This route is local-only; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, deployment, and production effects remain held. ## Purpose and audience A proposal-only review job for Tilly to reconcile claims with source records, citations, instrument outputs, qualification checks, grants, and publication boundaries without approving her own evidence or changing another agent's source. - Tilly - PointGuard reviewers - agents submitting claims - Notebook record owners ## Required or proposed record references The list defines expected record classes. It does not assert that any instance exists. - source record with canonical ID, origin, locator, SHA-256, provenance, revision, lifecycle, and links - claim record with exact wording, owner, scope, status, and supporting evidence links - citation-check record - instrument-work record - qualification record - grant dossier - public-claim review record - contradiction or unresolved-question record - approval or held-decision record - agent-log receipt ## Route contract The links below are this site's admitted canonical public records. Source-lane route suggestions are proposals only and are not represented as live or canonical until separately admitted. [01**overview**/docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/]()[02**tools**/docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/tools/]()[03**forms**/docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/forms/]()[04**field guides**/docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/field-guides/]()[05**qualification**/docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/qualification/]() ### Held source-proposed extensions - /docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/evidence-reconciliation-workflow/ - /docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/qualification-checks/ - /docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/contradictions-and-receipts/ - /docs/jobs/tilly-evidence-reconciliation/publication-and-commitment-gates/ These extension paths are not generated by this record and must not be treated as resolving routes. ## Public claim boundary Allowed items below are source-lane proposals, not verified current-state claims. ### Candidate claims allowed after source review - A proposal may state that this job is designed to reconcile claims with supplied evidence. - A proposal may describe recorded review states such as Needs review or Held when backed by local records. - A proposal may identify the named review responsibilities, tools, guides, and principal gates from the source record. ### Claims held - Tilly has approved any evidence or publication. - Any claim is qualified, funded, credentialed, published, customer-indexed, or production-ready. - Any provider, database, credential, customer, publication, upload, message-send, or external system connection exists. - Any instrument output proves a claim without human review and source-backed interpretation. - Any current GuthHub route is a connected production feature or canonical external system. - Any grant dossier or qualification record constitutes an awarded grant or granted credential. ## Sources and evidence These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment. - `agents/index.html#tilly` - `source_record:job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation` - `job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation` - `Observed native contract: Notebook records, deadlines, PointGuard, lifecycle, provenance, and held web boundary` - `App routes: /app/pointguard/, /app/notebook/agent-logs/, /app/notebook/approvals/, /app/notebook/field-guides/, /app/notebook/search/` - `Allowed instruments: checksum-verifier` - `Allowed instruments: binary-text-diff-similarity-ratio` - `source record job:tilly:evidence-reconciliation` - `Observed native contract: PointGuard` - `Observed native contract: records` - `Observed native contract: deadlines` - `Observed native contract: web boundary` - `App route /app/pointguard/` - `App route /app/notebook/field-guides/` - `App route /app/notebook/agent-logs/` - `App route /app/notebook/approvals/` - `App route /app/notebook/search/` - `Allowed instrument checksum-verifier` - `OBSERVED_NATIVE_CONTRACT.records` - `OBSERVED_NATIVE_CONTRACT.pointguard` - `OBSERVED_NATIVE_CONTRACT.deadlines` - `APP_ROUTES:/app/pointguard/` - `APP_ROUTES:/app/notebook/approvals/` - `APP_ROUTES:/app/notebook/field-guides/` - `APP_ROUTES:/app/notebook/agent-logs/` - `ALLOWED_INSTRUMENTS:checksum-verifier` - `ALLOWED_INSTRUMENTS:date-duration-calculator`