Source: https://guthlabs.ai/docs/jobs/tilly-independent-review/field-guides/

job / candidate

# Independent review — field guides

The distinct field guides record for Independent review. This page is proposal-only.

Status: **proposed**Lifecycle: **candidate**

## Record status

**Record ID**: job:tilly:independent-review

**Parent lifecycle**: candidate

**Page lane**: docs_urls

**Lane lifecycle**: proposed

**Owner**: Tilly

**Owner role**: Pointguard and independent reviewer

**Owner status**: WORKING

**Qualification result**: NOT RUN · held for evidence and human review

**Working browser surface:** [Agent jobs — builder overview](<https://guthlabs.ai/guth.html#builder>) — Inspect the package and stage a local project. This route is local-only; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, deployment, and production effects remain held.

## Related field-guide records

- /app/notebook/field-guides/

Source-proposed guide paths are references, not proof that those paths resolve.

## Operating sequence

- Receive and record the review brief, target IDs, requester, scope, deadline, and conflict-of-interest declaration.

- Open the canonical source records and inspect provenance, revisions, source locators, attachments, and existing receipts.

- Inventory the relevant instrument packets, qualification records, grant dossiers, citations, and public-claim materials.

- Check each claim or qualification requirement against its cited evidence and record exact gaps, contradictions, and scope limits.

- Separate verified support, unsupported assertions, unresolved questions, and recommendations; do not silently repair source material.

- Create a review receipt linking the examined records, checks performed, findings, limitations, and disposition.

- Route recommendations to the appropriate owner for local approval or hold; preserve any refusal or escalation as a record.

- Schedule follow-up workbacks for missing evidence, rechecks, or owner decisions.

- Close only when the receipt is complete, unresolved items have owners and deadlines, and publication or external effects remain explicitly held.

## Handoff boundary

- Self-approval or conflict of interest can invalidate the review.

- A draft recommendation may be mistaken for approval, qualification, publication, or deployment.

- Citation presence alone may be mistaken for evidentiary support.

- Instrument catalog status may be treated as proof of a connected provider or production capability.

- A missing source hash, locator, revision, or attachment can make a receipt non-reproducible.

- Contradictions may be suppressed when records are summarized too aggressively.

- Grant or funding review may be mistaken for a funding commitment.

- Credential review may be mistaken for credential issuance or access.

- Changing another agent’s source would violate the stated authority boundary.

- Private or held evidence may be exposed through an overly broad public route.

## Sources and evidence

These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.

- `agents/index.html#tilly`

- `source_record:job:tilly:independent-review`

- `Observed native contract: PointGuard persistent cross-app context surface; specialist apps remain execution and canonical-record owners.`

- `Observed native contract: Notebook records preserve canonical IDs, provenance, source locators, source SHA-256, revisions, lifecycle, tags, links, attachments, and record revisions.`

- `Observed native contract: Notebook approvals support Needs review, Approved, and Held states with receipts.`

- `Observed native contract: current GuthHub routes are local prototypes or indexes; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, and production effects are held.`

- `observed_native_contract.records`

- `observed_native_contract.pointguard`

- `observed_native_contract.web_boundary`

- `app:/app/pointguard/`

- `app:/app/notebook/agent-logs/`

- `app:/app/notebook/approvals/`

- `app:/app/notebook/notes/`

- `app:/app/notebook/files/`

- `app:/app/notebook/field-guides/`

- `app:/app/notebook/search/`

- `allowed_instrument:checksum-verifier`

- `allowed_instrument:binary-text-diff-similarity-ratio`

- `allowed_instrument:url-query-string-parser`