Source: https://guthlabs.ai/docs/jobs/tilly-independent-review/ job / candidate # Independent review A bounded review job for Tilly to examine instruments, qualification evidence, grants, citations, and public claims; identify contradictions or unsupported scope; and preserve review receipts without approving her own evidence, changing another agent’s source, committing funding, granting credentials, or publishing claims. Status: **candidate**Lifecycle: **candidate** ## Record status **Record ID**: job:tilly:independent-review **Parent lifecycle**: candidate **Page lane**: catalog overview **Lane lifecycle**: candidate **Owner**: Tilly **Owner role**: Pointguard and independent reviewer **Owner status**: WORKING **Qualification result**: NOT RUN · held for evidence and human review **Working browser surface:** [Agent jobs — builder overview]() — Inspect the package and stage a local project. This route is local-only; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, deployment, and production effects remain held. ## Purpose and audience A bounded review job for Tilly to examine instruments, qualification evidence, grants, citations, and public claims; identify contradictions or unsupported scope; and preserve review receipts without approving her own evidence, changing another agent’s source, committing funding, granting credentials, or publishing claims. - Tilly - PointGuard users - agent owners - reviewers - publication approvers - funding reviewers ## Required or proposed record references The list defines expected record classes. It does not assert that any instance exists. - source-labelled review brief - instrument packet - qualification record - grant dossier - citation-check record - claim examination record - contradiction or gap record - review receipt - approval or hold decision - deadline and workback to-do ## Route contract The links below are this site's admitted canonical public records. Source-lane route suggestions are proposals only and are not represented as live or canonical until separately admitted. [01**overview**/docs/jobs/tilly-independent-review/]()[02**tools**/docs/jobs/tilly-independent-review/tools/]()[03**forms**/docs/jobs/tilly-independent-review/forms/]()[04**field guides**/docs/jobs/tilly-independent-review/field-guides/]()[05**qualification**/docs/jobs/tilly-independent-review/qualification/]() ### Held source-proposed extensions - /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/ - /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/evidence-review/ - /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/qualification-checks/ - /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/grant-dossiers/ - /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/public-claim-routes/ - /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/failure-states/ These extension paths are not generated by this record and must not be treated as resolving routes. ## Public claim boundary Allowed items below are source-lane proposals, not verified current-state claims. ### Candidate claims allowed after source review - Tilly is proposed as the owner role for PointGuard and independent review. - The job is designed to inspect evidence, citations, qualifications, instruments, grants, and public-claim support. - The package preserves review findings, contradictions, limitations, and receipts. - The supplied source record identifies final publication, funding commitments, credential access, and changes to another agent’s source as principal gates. ### Claims held - Any claim that an instrument, agent, grant, credential, or project is qualified, funded, published, connected, deployed, or production-ready. - Any claim that a provider, database, customer index, publication route, or credential access exists. - Any claim that Tilly approved her own evidence or completed a principal gate. - Any claim that a contradiction has been resolved without a new owner-reviewed receipt. - Any customer-facing, public, financial, or credentialing outcome. ## Sources and evidence These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment. - `agents/index.html#tilly` - `source_record:job:tilly:independent-review` - `Observed native contract: PointGuard persistent cross-app context surface; specialist apps remain execution and canonical-record owners.` - `Observed native contract: Notebook records preserve canonical IDs, provenance, source locators, source SHA-256, revisions, lifecycle, tags, links, attachments, and record revisions.` - `Observed native contract: Notebook approvals support Needs review, Approved, and Held states with receipts.` - `Observed native contract: current GuthHub routes are local prototypes or indexes; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, and production effects are held.` - `observed_native_contract.records` - `observed_native_contract.pointguard` - `observed_native_contract.web_boundary` - `app:/app/pointguard/` - `app:/app/notebook/agent-logs/` - `app:/app/notebook/approvals/` - `app:/app/notebook/notes/` - `app:/app/notebook/files/` - `app:/app/notebook/field-guides/` - `app:/app/notebook/search/` - `allowed_instrument:checksum-verifier` - `allowed_instrument:binary-text-diff-similarity-ratio` - `allowed_instrument:url-query-string-parser` - `job:tilly:independent-review:qualification`