Source: https://guthlabs.ai/docs/tools/claim-examiner/boundaries/

tool / candidate

# Claim examiner — boundaries

The distinct boundaries record for Claim examiner. This page is proposal-only.

Status: **proposed**Lifecycle: **candidate**

## Record status

**Record ID**: tool:claim-examiner

**Parent lifecycle**: candidate

**Page lane**: contract boundaries

**Lane lifecycle**: proposed

**Owner**: Tilly, Socrates

**Owner role**: Pointguard and independent reviewer, University guide and tutor entity

**Owner status**: Not separately recorded

**Qualification result**: NOT RUN · held for evidence and human review

**Working browser surface:** [Tools — overview](<https://guthlabs.ai/labs.html#tools>) — Inspect the tool contract, usage, boundaries, and proposed qualification checks. This route is local-only; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, deployment, and production effects remain held.

## Hazards and failure states

- False authority from an unqualified or unconnected implementation

- Self-review or conflicted approval

- Suppression or misrepresentation of contradictory evidence

- Invented primary sources or citations

- Draft language being mistaken for a public claim

- Tutoring being mistaken for authorization or professional advice

- Unreviewed high-stakes instruction

- Unauthorized access to student identity data or external enrollment

- Unverified instrument qualification or deployment

- Overstating evidence in grant, website, course, or curriculum materials

## Claims potentially allowed after source review

- The proposal defines a bounded claim-examination workflow

- Tilly and Socrates are listed as owners in the supplied source record

- The tool may compare supplied claims and evidence and mark uncertainty proposal-only

- The source record lists 8 principal gates and 6 never-rules.

- Outputs require records, independent review, and escalation where applicable

## Claims held

- The implementation, connection, qualification, deployment, and operational authority are unproven

- No public claim, funding commitment, credential decision, curriculum claim, enrollment action, or high-stakes instruction is approved

- No source may be invented, concealed, or changed through this tool

- No customer use, performance, current metric, or effect is established

- No compatible instrument is asserted because the supplied record does not identify an exact required instrument slug

## Source gates and never-rules

The source record provides 8 principal gates and 6 never-rules. This page does not infer or add to those counts.

- Final publication

- Funding commitments

- Credential access

- Changes to another agent's source

- High-stakes instruction

- Student identity data

- External enrollment

- Published curriculum claims

- Approve her own evidence

- Hide a contradiction

- Turn a draft into a public claim

- Invent a primary source

- Hide disputed evidence

- Confuse tutoring with authority

## Sources and evidence

These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.

- `source_record:tool:claim-examiner`

- `agents/index.html#tilly`

- `agents/index.html#socrates`