A Guth Labs publication ↗
Back to News

Bain finds retail specialists often outperform their market share in AI shopping answers

A sage-green magnifying glass highlights one small shop among miniature cream storefronts.
AI-generated editorial illustration

Bain & Company reported on November 20 that specialty retailers often appeared in AI shopping answers more frequently than their market share would suggest. For its retail study, Bain used data from Profound to analyze more than 4,400 shopping prompts across four retail categories, with more than 300,000 runs across major language models. The results varied by category and do not show that specialists always outrank general retailers.

Bain separately reported survey results showing that nearly 33% of U.S. consumers and 36% of European consumers said they used AI assistants at some point while shopping, up from 19% and 8% respectively in 2025. Direct referrals from AI assistants still accounted for less than 1% of retailer web traffic overall, Bain said. That traffic converted to purchases at a rate 90% higher than non-AI traffic in its analysis. That comparison does not establish that the assistant caused the difference.

The study matters because being mentioned in an AI answer and receiving a visit from that answer are two different things. A shopper can get a recommendation, then look up a retailer directly, without leaving an AI referral for the store to measure.

Sources and citations

Revision history

Published .