French expert commission urges stronger safeguards for AI assistants and children

A French expert commission has delivered 18 recommendations aimed at protecting people who use generative AI, placing chatbot design, children's safety and AI-enabled toys under scrutiny. The Élysée published its account of the report on November 10. The proposals are recommendations for public action, not a new law taking effect that day. Élysée announcement
The report, titled Protéger sans empêcher, examines vulnerabilities associated with chatbots, AI companions and AI-enabled toys. Its premise is that useful applications and stronger protections should be developed together, rather than treating safety as a question to consider only after adoption.
A commissioned review, not a product verdict
The Conseil de l'IA et du numérique assembled a nine-member expert group led by AI researcher Serena Villata and psychiatrists Raphaël Gaillard and Amine Benyamina. The work included 55 hearings involving health professionals, researchers, businesses and child-protection organizations, according to the presidency. The council's mandate originated in February. Élysée account, Council project page
That process provides a multidisciplinary policy assessment. It should not be mistaken for a clinical diagnosis of individual users or proof that every chatbot produces the same effects. Different designs, contexts and audiences require evidence appropriate to the claim being made.
The proposals focus on design and access
The report's first recommendation would prohibit conversational-AI design techniques that exploit or create vulnerabilities to generate dependence or engagement. A second calls for strong protections for services accessible to minors, including appropriate safeguards, independent evaluation and sanctions for non-compliance. It also calls for independent evaluation before deployment and monitoring afterward. Commission report
The commission separately recommends prior market authorization and restrictive age thresholds for toys incorporating generative AI. That is a proposed approach to a specific product category, not an announcement that all AI toys have been prohibited. Report, recommendation 11
These proposals shift attention from an isolated answer to the surrounding interaction. A service can provide useful information while also repeatedly encouraging a person to return or disclose more. Evaluating that experience requires examining sequences of exchanges and product incentives, not only whether individual responses contain forbidden words.
Implementation would require further choices
If policymakers take up the recommendations, they will need to define the covered services, the evidence expected from providers and the authority responsible for assessment. Age checks would also require careful attention to privacy and accessibility. A protective setting is only meaningful if it works for the users it is intended to protect.
The report gives developers a reason to examine engagement features, child-access assumptions and post-launch monitoring now. It does not settle how every recommendation will become enforceable. The next test is whether public authorities translate the review into clear, measurable obligations while preserving beneficial uses of the technology.
Sources and citations
Revision history
Published .