Page actions
instrument mechanism / verified-clean
HVAC Heating/Cooling Load Estimator (Envelope Method) mechanism
The inspectable method record for HVAC Heating/Cooling Load Estimator (Envelope Method), kept separate from implementation and qualification.
Model scope
The arithmetic algorithms are standard for a rough envelope-only estimate, but the spec needs explicit unit selection, heating/cooling sign convention, air-property convention for the infiltration factors, and validation rules. Verdict is needs review because those ambiguities materially affect computed outputs. The stated honest label is appropriate but should also explicitly say that solar, internal, latent, duct, ground, and thermal-bridge loads are excluded.
- Q=U·A·ΔT is the standard steady-state envelope conduction method when U, area, and temperature difference use compatible units.
- Heating and cooling loads must be separated by direction: use indoor minus outdoor for heating and outdoor minus indoor for cooling, with the non-applicable load reported as zero. The specification does not explicitly define this sign convention.
- The infiltration constants are approximate air-property conversions, not universal constants. 1.08 requires CFM and degrees Fahrenheit and assumes approximately 0.075 lb/ft³ air density and 0.24 Btu/(lb·°F) specific heat. 1.23 requires L/s and degrees Celsius or kelvin temperature difference and assumes approximately 1.225 kg/m³ air density and 1005 J/(kg·K) specific heat.
- A typical U-value table is construction-dependent; U-values must identify assembly, insulation level, framing, glazing, films, and whether the value is center-of-glass or whole-assembly.
- The method omits solar gains, internal gains, latent loads, thermal bridges, ground-contact conduction, duct losses, ventilation requirements, thermal storage, and equipment/system effects; it is not a complete ACCA Manual J calculation.
Units and conventions
- US conduction: area in ft², U in Btu/(h·ft²·°F), temperature difference in °F, output in Btu/h.
- US infiltration: airflow in CFM, temperature difference in °F, output in Btu/h; 1.08 is an assumed standard-air conversion factor.
- SI conduction: area in m², U in W/(m²·K), temperature difference in K or °C difference, output in W.
- SI infiltration: airflow in L/s, temperature difference in K or °C difference, output in W; 1.23 assumes approximately 1.225 kg/m³ air density and 1005 J/(kg·K) specific heat.
- The vectors use heating load = positive conduction and infiltration when indoor temperature exceeds outdoor temperature, and cooling load = positive conduction and infiltration when outdoor temperature exceeds indoor temperature.
Inspectable vector
One of 4 source-bound review vectors:
{
"inputs": {
"system": "US heating",
"surfaces": [
{
"name": "wall",
"area_ft2": 800,
"U_Btu_h_ft2_F": 0.07692307692307693
},
{
"name": "window",
"area_ft2": 100,
"U_Btu_h_ft2_F": 0.5
},
{
"name": "roof",
"area_ft2": 800,
"U_Btu_h_ft2_F": 0.05263157894736842
}
],
"indoor_temperature_F": 70,
"outdoor_temperature_F": 20,
"infiltration_CFM": 100
},
"expected_outputs": {
"temperature_difference_F": 50,
"conduction_Btu_h": 7682.186234818,
"infiltration_Btu_h": 5400,
"total_heating_load_Btu_h": 13082.186234818,
"total_cooling_load_Btu_h": 0
},
"reference_data": {
"wall_nominal_R_value_h_ft2_F_per_Btu": 13,
"wall_U_Btu_h_ft2_F": "1/13 = 0.07692307692307693",
"wall_source_convention": "Widely tabulated standard nominal insulation value, R-13",
"roof_nominal_R_value_h_ft2_F_per_Btu": 19,
"roof_U_Btu_h_ft2_F": "1/19 = 0.05263157894736842",
"roof_source_convention": "Widely tabulated standard nominal insulation value, R-19",
"window_U_Btu_h_ft2_F": 0.5,
"window_source_convention": "Widely tabulated standard value for a representative modern double-glazed window",
"US_infiltration_factor_Btu_h_per_CFM_F": 1.08,
"infiltration_factor_source_convention": "Widely tabulated HVAC standard-air conversion value"
},
"working": "ΔT = 70 − 20 = 50°F. Wall = (1/13)·800·50 = 3076.923076923 Btu/h. Window = 0.50·100·50 = 2500 Btu/h. Roof = (1/19)·800·50 = 2105.263157895 Btu/h. Conduction = 3076.923076923 + 2500 + 2105.263157895 = 7682.186234818 Btu/h. Infiltration = 1.08·100·50 = 5400 Btu/h. Total heating = 7682.186234818 + 5400 = 13082.186234818 Btu/h. Since outdoor temperature is lower, cooling load = 0."
}Failure boundary
Known limit · flagged by the author
The extreme infiltration input produces a mathematical result of 1.08e310 Btu/h, which overflows ordinary IEEE-754 floating-point arithmetic to a non-finite value. The convention probe also exposes a sign ambiguity: reversing the definition of ΔT changes the reported result from +8960 to -8960 Btu/h even though the physical condition is heating.
Other records
Sources and evidence
These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.
VERIFIED_LEDGER.jsonevidence-tranche7/tranche7-results.jsonBOUNDARY_HAZARD_CATALOG.json