Claim examiner — boundaries

Record status

Record ID

tool:claim-examiner

Parent lifecycle

candidate

Page lane

contract boundaries

Lane lifecycle

proposed

Owner

Tilly, Socrates

Owner role

Pointguard and independent reviewer, University guide and tutor entity

Owner status

Not separately recorded

Qualification result

NOT RUN · held for evidence and human review

Working browser surface: Tools — overview — Inspect the tool contract, usage, boundaries, and proposed qualification checks. This route is local-only; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, deployment, and production effects remain held.

Hazards and failure states

• False authority from an unqualified or unconnected implementation
• Self-review or conflicted approval
• Suppression or misrepresentation of contradictory evidence
• Invented primary sources or citations
• Draft language being mistaken for a public claim
• Tutoring being mistaken for authorization or professional advice
• Unreviewed high-stakes instruction
• Unauthorized access to student identity data or external enrollment
• Unverified instrument qualification or deployment
• Overstating evidence in grant, website, course, or curriculum materials

Claims potentially allowed after source review

• The proposal defines a bounded claim-examination workflow
• Tilly and Socrates are listed as owners in the supplied source record
• The tool may compare supplied claims and evidence and mark uncertainty proposal-only
• The source record lists 8 principal gates and 6 never-rules.
• Outputs require records, independent review, and escalation where applicable

Claims held

• The implementation, connection, qualification, deployment, and operational authority are unproven
• No public claim, funding commitment, credential decision, curriculum claim, enrollment action, or high-stakes instruction is approved
• No source may be invented, concealed, or changed through this tool
• No customer use, performance, current metric, or effect is established
• No compatible instrument is asserted because the supplied record does not identify an exact required instrument slug

Source gates and never-rules

The source record provides 8 principal gates and 6 never-rules. This page does not infer or add to those counts.

• Final publication
• Funding commitments
• Credential access
• Changes to another agent's source
• High-stakes instruction
• Student identity data
• External enrollment
• Published curriculum claims

• Approve her own evidence
• Hide a contradiction
• Turn a draft into a public claim
• Invent a primary source
• Hide disputed evidence
• Confuse tutoring with authority

Sources and evidence

These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.

• source_record:tool:claim-examiner
• agents/index.html#tilly
• agents/index.html#socrates