Independent review

Record status

Record ID

job:tilly:independent-review

Parent lifecycle

candidate

Page lane

catalog overview

Lane lifecycle

candidate

Owner

Tilly

Owner role

Pointguard and independent reviewer

Owner status

WORKING

Qualification result

NOT RUN · held for evidence and human review

Working browser surface: Agent jobs — builder overview — Inspect the package and stage a local project. This route is local-only; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, deployment, and production effects remain held.

Purpose and audience

A bounded review job for Tilly to examine instruments, qualification evidence, grants, citations, and public claims; identify contradictions or unsupported scope; and preserve review receipts without approving her own evidence, changing another agent’s source, committing funding, granting credentials, or publishing claims.

• Tilly
• PointGuard users
• agent owners
• reviewers
• publication approvers
• funding reviewers

Required or proposed record references

The list defines expected record classes. It does not assert that any instance exists.

• source-labelled review brief
• instrument packet
• qualification record
• grant dossier
• citation-check record
• claim examination record
• contradiction or gap record
• review receipt
• approval or hold decision
• deadline and workback to-do

Route contract

The links below are this site's admitted canonical public records. Source-lane route suggestions are proposals only and are not represented as live or canonical until separately admitted.

Held source-proposed extensions

• /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/
• /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/evidence-review/
• /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/qualification-checks/
• /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/grant-dossiers/
• /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/public-claim-routes/
• /docs/jobs/tilly/independent-review/failure-states/

These extension paths are not generated by this record and must not be treated as resolving routes.

Public claim boundary

Allowed items below are source-lane proposals, not verified current-state claims.

Candidate claims allowed after source review

• Tilly is proposed as the owner role for PointGuard and independent review.
• The job is designed to inspect evidence, citations, qualifications, instruments, grants, and public-claim support.
• The package preserves review findings, contradictions, limitations, and receipts.
• The supplied source record identifies final publication, funding commitments, credential access, and changes to another agent’s source as principal gates.

Claims held

• Any claim that an instrument, agent, grant, credential, or project is qualified, funded, published, connected, deployed, or production-ready.
• Any claim that a provider, database, customer index, publication route, or credential access exists.
• Any claim that Tilly approved her own evidence or completed a principal gate.
• Any claim that a contradiction has been resolved without a new owner-reviewed receipt.
• Any customer-facing, public, financial, or credentialing outcome.

Sources and evidence

These pointers bind the page to evidence. They do not grant authority or collapse verification into deployment.

• agents/index.html#tilly
• source_record:job:tilly:independent-review
• Observed native contract: PointGuard persistent cross-app context surface; specialist apps remain execution and canonical-record owners.
• Observed native contract: Notebook records preserve canonical IDs, provenance, source locators, source SHA-256, revisions, lifecycle, tags, links, attachments, and record revisions.
• Observed native contract: Notebook approvals support Needs review, Approved, and Held states with receipts.
• Observed native contract: current GuthHub routes are local prototypes or indexes; provider, credential, database, customer, publication, and production effects are held.
• observed_native_contract.records
• observed_native_contract.pointguard
• observed_native_contract.web_boundary
• app:/app/pointguard/
• app:/app/notebook/agent-logs/
• app:/app/notebook/approvals/
• app:/app/notebook/notes/
• app:/app/notebook/files/
• app:/app/notebook/field-guides/
• app:/app/notebook/search/
• allowed_instrument:checksum-verifier
• allowed_instrument:binary-text-diff-similarity-ratio
• allowed_instrument:url-query-string-parser
• job:tilly:independent-review:qualification